Learn how to measure and compare biodiversity at two sites using repeatable quadrat or transect surveys, species richness, evenness and the Shannon diversity index. This guide includes a worked calculation, a comparison table and a field-recording template suitable for coursework, monitoring and conservation projects.
Overview
Biodiversity is more than the number of species present. A useful comparison considers both species richness—how many different species are recorded—and relative abundance—how evenly individuals are distributed among those species. A site with four species represented by equal numbers may support a more diverse community than a site with four species dominated by one common species.
To compare biodiversity reliably, decide in advance what you will measure, use the same sampling effort at each site and record observations in a consistent way. A simple workflow is:
- Define the question, sites and sampling area.
- Select a repeatable method, such as quadrats, a belt transect or a line transect.
- Record each species and the number of individuals, or an agreed cover or frequency measure.
- Calculate richness and, where abundance data are suitable, the Shannon diversity index and evenness.
- Interpret the results alongside habitat conditions, sampling limitations and uncertainty.
The method should match the organisms being studied. Quadrats are often practical for plants or slow-moving organisms. Transects help reveal how a community changes along an environmental gradient, such as from a path into woodland or from the bank of a stream across its floodplain. For broader garden monitoring, the garden biodiversity survey guide provides a useful seasonal recording framework.
What to track
Choose a sampling design
Before entering the field, define the target habitat, survey boundary, quadrat size and number of samples. Place quadrats randomly if the aim is to estimate the habitat as a whole. Use a systematic pattern, such as every five metres along a transect, when you need a repeatable spatial sequence. Avoid choosing only visually interesting patches, because this can introduce observer bias.
Keep effort comparable. If Site A has ten quadrats and Site B has two, a higher species count at Site A may simply reflect greater sampling effort. Use the same quadrat dimensions, number of samples, observation time, search area and identification rules whenever practical.
Record abundance consistently
For plants, count individual stems only when individuals can be distinguished reliably. In grasses, mosses or clonal plants, percentage cover or presence–absence may be more defensible. For mobile animals, record sightings using a fixed time, distance or trapping effort, following appropriate welfare and access rules. Do not combine raw counts from one site with percentage cover from another in the same calculation.
Record environmental variables that could help explain differences, such as canopy cover, soil moisture, vegetation height, light level, visible disturbance or water conditions. These measurements do not replace biodiversity indices, but they make the comparison more informative. For aquatic fieldwork, pair biological observations with a consistent water-quality method; see the UK river health field assessment guide for a related approach.
Measures to calculate
| Measure | What it tells you | Key limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Species richness | The number of species recorded | It ignores how abundant each species is and increases with sampling effort |
| Relative abundance | The proportion of individuals belonging to each species | It depends on reliable and comparable counts |
| Shannon diversity index | A combined measure of richness and the distribution of abundances | Values are meaningful mainly when survey methods and taxonomic resolution match |
| Shannon evenness | How close abundances are to an equal distribution | It is usually interpreted alongside richness and the index, not alone |
Calculate the Shannon index
The Shannon diversity index is commonly written as:
H′ = −Σ(pi ln pi)
Here, pi is the proportion of all recorded individuals belonging to species i, and ln is the natural logarithm. Shannon evenness can be calculated as:
J′ = H′ / ln(S)
S is species richness. If your course or project specifies a different logarithm or index convention, follow that convention consistently and state it clearly.
Worked example
Suppose two sites each contain four recorded species. At Site A, the counts are 20, 10, 5 and 5, giving a total of 40 individuals. The proportions are 0.50, 0.25, 0.125 and 0.125. Substituting these values gives:
H′ ≈ 1.213
Because Site A has four species, its evenness is approximately 1.213 ÷ ln(4) = 0.875. At Site B, suppose the four species each have 10 individuals. Its richness is also four, but its proportions are 0.25 each, producing:
H′ ≈ 1.386 and J′ = 1.000
Both sites have the same species richness. Site B has the higher Shannon index because its individuals are distributed more evenly. This does not automatically mean Site B is ecologically healthier: the identity of the species, habitat condition, survey season and conservation question still matter.
Reusable field-survey recording template
Use one row per species per sampling unit, or create a matrix with species as rows and quadrats as columns:
- Project and date: ____________________
- Site and habitat: ____________________
- Observer(s): ____________________
- Method and quadrat size: ____________________
- Sampling location or transect distance: ____________________
- Species name or identification code: ____________________
- Count, cover or presence–absence value: ____________________
- Environmental notes: ____________________
- Identification confidence or unresolved record: ____________________
Cadence and checkpoints
A single survey is a snapshot. To monitor change, repeat the same design at a planned interval. Monthly surveys can capture rapid seasonal changes where conditions and identification skills allow. Quarterly or seasonal surveys may be more practical for school projects and habitat comparisons. Record the exact date, weather, recent management and any disturbance each time.
At every checkpoint, ask:
- Was the same area surveyed with the same effort?
- Were the same taxonomic groups included?
- Did the season, weather or observer change?
- Did richness, total abundance or evenness change together?
- Were new species found because of genuine change or more intensive searching?
For a long-term record, retain the original species-by-sample table rather than saving only the final index. Raw data allow calculations to be checked, identification changes to be documented and later analyses to use improved methods.
How to interpret changes
Do not treat a higher index as a complete verdict on habitat quality. A site may gain common generalist species while losing a less abundant specialist. Conversely, a temporary reduction in visible abundance could follow mowing, drought or another disturbance without indicating permanent ecosystem decline.
Look for patterns across several measures. A fall in richness accompanied by lower total abundance may suggest a meaningful change, but it still needs investigation. A stable richness value with a falling evenness score may indicate increasing dominance by one or two species. Compare the species lists as well as the numbers: replacement of one species by another can leave the index deceptively similar.
Sampling limitations are part of the result. Small samples may miss rare species, while difficult identification can create false differences between sites. State the number and size of quadrats, sampling dates, calculation method, taxonomic level and any exclusions. If the sites differ in habitat area or accessibility, describe that limitation rather than implying that the index alone proves a cause.
When to revisit
Revisit the survey on a monthly or quarterly schedule if you are tracking seasonal change, restoration or disturbance. Repeat the analysis after each comparable field visit, but avoid declaring a trend from one unusual observation. A practical minimum is to compare several sampling occasions under similar seasonal conditions.
Update the method when the project question changes, the habitat is altered, identification guidance improves or an assessment specification introduces a different index. Before each field session, check equipment, permissions, safety arrangements and the species list. Afterward, verify totals, recalculate proportions and keep a dated version of the dataset.
For your next survey, choose two comparable sites, prepare identical recording sheets, collect equal sampling effort and calculate richness before moving to Shannon diversity. Then write a short interpretation that separates what the data show from what they cannot establish. This habit makes biodiversity comparisons more repeatable and gives future surveys a dependable baseline.